Skip to content

"Historic manors puzzle over retrogression following the announced budget"

After half a century since the significant exhibition at the V&A, the country house encounters substantial challenges. Lucy Denton interviews property owners and organizations to discuss potential future scenarios.

"Historical estate homes reflect on their current state after the released budget decision...
"Historical estate homes reflect on their current state after the released budget decision confounds them"

"Historic manors puzzle over retrogression following the announced budget"

The Autumn Budget has sparked concerns among those who manage and own Scotland's historic estates and castles. Comparing the aftermath of the budget to the harrowing 1974 V&A exhibition on the Destruction of the Country House, Norman Hudson OBE, chairman of the Historic Houses Foundation, warns that the supporting assets of these historic properties are being sliced away.

The focus of the concerns revolves around the Inheritance Tax changes, effective from April 2026. These changes will implement a combined cap of £1 million for Business Property Relief (BPR) and Agricultural Property Relief (APR) and a 20% rate above that. Chancellor Rachel Reeves' announcements have alarmed many, including Mr. Hudson, due to their potential impacts on the financial viability of privately-owned estates.

Orlando Rock, joint custodian of the spectacular Elizabethan Burghley House near Stamford, echoes these concerns. He points out that the changes to both the minimum wage and National Insurance liabilities are a killer, as they have a disproportionate effect on the bottom line, inevitably reducing investment, estate hiring, and staff pay rises.

These changes could lead to reluctance of successors to inherited estates to take them on, which is deeply damaging to growth, according to Ben Cowell, director general of Historic Houses. Larger estates might be better able to withstand a monetary hit, but those of middling status are more vulnerable, especially where diversification means reliance on paper-thin margins, and where there is less to fall back on.

Nicholas Watson of the land management team at Strutt and Parker warns that farms and estates have traditionally been low-yielding asset classes. He suggests that proactive succession and estate planning may help to mitigate the liability. However, the drip-drip effects of the Budget could trigger a pruning of assets in order to stay afloat or outright disposal of buildings, land, and artworks, as well as curtailing of critical investment, events, and access.

Despite these concerns, Scotland's historic estates and castles continue to attract visitors. At Grade I Listed Hedingham Castle in Essex, 25,000 visitors and 70 weddings a year hosted by custodian Jason Lindsay not only fund a substantial repair bill but also contribute to the local economy, boost employment opportunities, and help support the community.

The article also discusses four houses for sale that allow one to live out their yuletide experiences, painting a picture of the allure that these historic properties hold, even in the face of financial uncertainty. However, the future of these estates and castles remains uncertain, and their preservation hangs in the balance.

Lucy Denton, a writer and architectural historian who has worked for Adam Architecture, Sotheby's, the BBC, The Times, and has written for various platforms, provides insight into the potential impacts of the Chancellor's announcements. She emphasises the importance of understanding the unique challenges faced by these properties and the need for thoughtful and considered solutions to ensure their survival.

In conclusion, the Autumn Budget has raised significant concerns among those who manage and own Scotland's historic estates and castles. The potential impacts on the financial viability of these properties are far-reaching and could have significant consequences for the preservation of these national treasures. It is a situation that requires careful consideration and thoughtful action to ensure the continued survival of these historic properties.

Read also:

Latest