Harassment is common among those who solicit promises
In the heart of Germany, bottle collectors in Hamburg are encountering challenges with supermarkets and discount stores refusing to accept bottle deposit returns, primarily due to legal and operational constraints.
Under the German bottle deposit system (Pfand), consumers pay a deposit (usually 25 cents) on bottles and cans, which is refundable upon return at retailers. According to the law, traders are obligated to take back bottles and cans of the same type they sell, ensuring the deposit can be reimbursed to the consumer[1].
However, the system presents challenges for collectors who gather many different bottle types from various sources, which may not match the inventory of the specific supermarket or discount store. Such stores may refuse returns outside their legal obligation to avoid operational disruption or losses, resulting in collectors being denied their legitimate deposits for bottles they want to return.
The legal framework for the deposit system is designed as a closed loop to encourage recycling. Stores have to comply by accepting returns of packaging they sell but are not generally required to accept all types from all sources[1]. While no detailed current news specifically about Hamburg supermarkets' refusal practices was found in recent search results, the general understanding of the German deposit law clarifies that refusal often stems from retailers complying strictly with the legal terms of accepting returns only for products they sell.
The Packaging Act obliges traders to accept one-way drink packaging free of charge and refund the deposit. Complaints to the waste authority rarely have serious consequences, as the damage in individual cases is usually low.
The Hamburg Consumer Center is receiving complaints about supermarkets and discount stores refusing to accept bottle deposit returns, particularly affecting bottle collectors. The Center claims that supermarkets are giving various reasons for refusal, such as unreadable labels, defective machines, or full warehouses. However, these reasons are often questionable, as many collectors report being harassed, banned, or even having the police called on them when attempting to return their bottles.
Edeka, Rewe, and Netto are reportedly receiving the most complaints about refusing bottle deposit returns. All three retailers claim to be fulfilling their legal return obligations. The Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart decided in 2023 that even dented cans must be accepted, further emphasizing the retailers' legal responsibilities.
To help bottle collectors navigate this issue, the Hamburg Consumer Center offers a pocket-sized card explaining the legal situation briefly. If acceptance is still refused, a complaint can be filed with the Hamburg Consumer Center. The Consumer Center also provides a sample letter for a complaint to the local waste authority.
Consumer protectionist Tristan Jorde has collected hundreds of complaints about this issue over the years. Despite the challenges faced by collectors, the deposit system remains an essential part of Germany's recycling efforts, and ongoing efforts are being made to improve the system and ensure fair treatment for all parties involved.
[1] Source: [Link to the official German deposit law website or relevant news article]
- Bottle collectors in Hamburg, despite their efforts to contribute to the German bottle deposit system, often encounter refusals from supermarkets and discount stores to accept bottle deposit returns, as retailers may follow the legal and operational constraints provided under the law that obliges them to accept returns only for products they sell.
- In the heart of Hamburg, individuals engaged in home-and-garden activities, such as lifestyle enthusiasts or those seeking deals-and-discounts for shopping, may encounter difficulties returning various bottle types, as supermarkets and discount stores may refuse returns outside their legal obligation, leading to denial of legitimate deposits for bottles under the German bottle deposit system.
